From DIY to home repairs and construction, a hammer is an essential tool to have. Whether you like to assume the role of a handyman around your household or simply need a tool for when there’s a nail in need of hammering, we’ve got you covered with the best hammers in 2023. And although hammers seem like straightforward, single-purpose tools, there are plenty of important data points to consider when choosing the right one for your projects. So let’s see what are the aspects you should take into account before buying a hammer and how you can identify the best model for your purposes. Let’s get started!
Chances are, you’re looking for a regular old nail hammer that can make a nice addition to your DIY collection. However, just to make sure we’ve covered our bases, let’s explore other types of hammers that you might find yourself needing at one time or another.
There are quite a few types of hammers, each best suited to specific types of tasks and work.
The most popular type of hammer and one that everyone would recognize regardless of their level of experience, the nail hammer is used for driving and pulling nails from wood.
The ball peen hammer sports a rounded ball on one end and a flat peen on the other. Ball peen hammers can be as light as 6 ounces or as heavy as 30 ounces. Ball peen hammers are usually used for more brutal work such as striking chisels or making gaskets. Ball peen hammers are most commonly used by machinists and metalworkers.
This is a lightweight hammer used in hammering nails without damaging the surface of the wood or workpiece. It is primarily used for smaller nails.
These are very heavy hammers designed to drive large nails into stubborn surfaces. The face of these hammers is textured to ensure that the nail doesn’t slip as it’s hit.
Also known as an upholstery hammer, this is a delicate tool with one magnetized face used for securing upholstery fabric into furniture.
Mallets are also known as soft-face hammers and they have a heavy head made from softer materials such as plastic or rubber. They’re used for striking and shaping delicate surfaces. A rubber mallet is best suited for tasks in which a hard metal hammer would damage the material.
Dead blow hammers are a type of mallet that has further engineering applied to it to minimize the damage it can do. Dead blow hammers are filled with sand or other material in order to absorb part of the impact.
A sledge hammer is a heavy-duty monster, meant to be wielded with two hands in demolition. Construction workers and house flippers most commonly use a sledge hammer. A sledge hammer is very powerful and can do a great deal of destruction, perfect for demolition and renovation projects.
If you want to learn more about the different types of hammers, BuildersSA has a helpful explanation video:
The hammerhead will be doing most of the high-octane work so its design, grip, and sturdiness are quite important.
First off, the hammerhead needs to be heavy enough. In fact, the head weight is one of the main ways to differentiate between hammers. Nail hammers are usually between 16 and 20 ounces, with the 20-ounce model being used for more heavy-duty jobs. Additionally, you will also find 8-ounce hammers which are great for tighter corners or easier jobs.
The face of the hammer can be smooth or textured. Smooth hammers are less likely to mar the wood or the surface area you are working with while textured face hammers offer more nail stability. There are also brands that advertise a larger face as a feature that helps with nail striking but we’re not yet convinced it makes a significant difference.
The handle on a hammer can be very important. If you’re mostly doing small projects around the house, then your best bet is a fiberglass or steel handle. While steel handles will likely cost more, they’re more durable. Fiberglass handles are usually lighter and they have a good grip but that comes at the expense of longevity.
Wood handles are also an option and they do tend to have a very pleasing classic look. That said, if you’re going to go in this direction we advise you to select a hammer with a more rigid handle as smooth wood can be very slippery.
The claw of the hammer is used for pulling out nails and it can be either straight or curved. This is a matter of personal preference, and if you find you work better with a curved claw, most hammers will have that option available. However, rip or straight claw works just as well and it’s the standard.
Some manufacturers come up with specific handles and steel designs meant to reduce vibration and therefore elbow pain which can happen when you’re using a hammer for extended periods of time.
Nail starter hammers feature powerful magnets that allow the wielder to place the nail exactly where they want it. They’re great for DIY projects where precision is key and they’re also pretty effective at preventing injury.
A new modern design, the curved handle is a relatively recent innovation. While most old-school purists don’t really understand this feature, a lot of enthusiasts feel that a curved handle can improve their grip and balance with a hammer and even eliminate fatigue.
Now that we’ve covered some of the basics let’s get into our top picks for the best nail hammers out there! We’ve covered a wide range of categories with models that vary in size, design, and price. Let’s jump right in!
If you’re looking for a nicely constructed, balanced hammer that can pack a punch despite its size, the YiyiToold Claw Hammer is the tool for you. The head is made from forged hardened steel and it has a good feel and weight.
This tool is affordable but don’t let that fool you. It’s sturdy and heavy enough to handle most jobs but small enough that it’s comfortable to carry around, especially if you don’t have a tool kit. The quality is top notch and the grip is solid. With a fiberglass handle that will dampen any vibration resulting from striking, this 13.7 inch, 16 oz hammer is just what you need for any odd job around the house, repairs or even construction work.
A quality tool that will last you a lifetime and never disappoint, the Estwing 16 oz hammer is made from one solid piece of steel and it looks and feels incredible. The leather handle cover makes for great grip without compromising aesthetics and the rip claw will come through every time, whether against nails or splitting wood.
This is truly a tool you can boast about. From casual wielders to hard core DIY enthusiasts, this is the kind of hammer that even the disinterested amateur will look upon in awe. It’s not only a durable tool, whose thin neck looks elegant but stands unbreakable. This is a conversation starter and a sure fire way to impress your neighbours.
Stubby, light weight and rust resistant, this 8 ounce forged alloy steel hammer is perfect for the odd job around the house. Small and handy, it’s portable enough that you won’t have to draw around a more powerful tool for simple jobs. The handle is slip-proof and shock resistant and the built-in magnetic holder will make hammering more convenient.
This tool will surprise with durability and weight but more than that, it’s designed for the kind of small jobs that so often get neglected. It’s ideal for precision jobs, where small handles are essential and limited maneuverability calls for a tool heavy enough to do the job without much swing. Great value for money!
A great looking oak handle hammer with a conveniently etched grip, the Edward tools claw hammer is versatile enough to be used for jobs big and small. A 16 ounce beauty that makes you reminisce about toolboxes from yesteryears, the wood handle is solid and the hammer head is made from durable forced carbon steel that will keep you company for a while.
A great tool with a classic feel, the Edward Tools Oak Claw Hammer comes with a lifetime warranty which speaks volumes about the brand’s confidence in their product and their commitment to high standards. Give it a swing!
Another 16 ouncer that delivers the IRWIN fiberglass hammer is sturdy, shock resistant and made to reduce fatigue. From the forged steel head to the ProTouch grip, this hammer is designed to absorb vibration and limit strain by leveraging a handle that uses texture as well as shape to fit seamlessly into your hands. You won’t need to tighten or readjust your grip to maintain precision with this Irwin hammer. The handle really makes for a seamless comfortable experience.
It’s the right size to do whatever job you throw at it and it’s heavy and reassuring to hold. The quality is excellent for the price and it will make a great addition to your tool box.
This hammer is made from high density carbon steel and it’s created to be a faithful companion throughout the years, resisting rust and wear and tear. The convenient size makes it the go to tool for tight corners and inconveniently placed nails. It’s comfortable to carry and it won’t impede your movements if you need to crawl or squeeze yourself to start hammering.
The magnetic nail starter adds another layer of convenience and the non slip handle is shock proof and very grip friendly. Strikingly effective for its size, this is the perfect tool for amateurs who want a sturdy but portable solution or for experienced handymen who are looking for something that works in a compact space.
The Craftsman fiberglass hammer is ambitious, durable and just plain cool to look at. It’s strategically reinforced in places where fiberglass hammers are most vulnerable and built for the long haul. A well made tool from a reputable brand at an affordable price, the Craftsman feels comfortably balanced without compromising on strength. It’s powerful enough to pull nails out of hardwood but precise enough to beat a nail without bruising the work surface.
The brand itself is reputable enough to justify a leap of faith, but be advised that while the hammer is well balanced enough to be called light weight, it is still a 16 ounce tool and can therefore be tiring to use after a while.
A: The best weight for a nail hammer is between 16 and 20 ounces. The 16 ounce hammer can usually handle whatever shop or household task you throw at it while the 20 ounce one will be better for demo work and less convenient to use for home use. Keep in mind though, that while a 20 ounce hammer can do everything a 16 ounce one can, the former will cause fatigue and elbow pain a lot faster.
A: Titanium hammers are better in certain circumstances and for certain projects because they are lighter and therefore easier to wield than steel hammers. This means that you will be able to hammer a nail with less fatigue and with fewer swings. However, this type of hammer can be quite pricey so you should make sure that you’ll get enough use out of it if you plan on splurging.
A: It depends on what you’re using the hammer for. In terms of durability, the strongest handle will be made out of steel, preferably from the same piece as the hammer head. However, that will also add some significant weight to the hammer itself making it harder to swing. A handle that is easy to grip and more light weight can sometimes be more suited for some tasks although you probably won’t get as much long term use out of it as with its steel counterpart.
The Woodsmith Review Team’s product reviews and in-depth guides are here to help you choose the best tools and gear to build great-looking projects confidently. The content is created by The Woodsmith Review Team. Woodsmith’s editorial staff is not involved. Woodsmith is reader-supported: When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.